Summit 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket vs Lzobxe Women's 3-in-1 Hooded Winter Coat

Buy the Summit 3-in-1 if you want a jacket you can actually trust in sustained rain and snow. Its 5,000 mm waterproof shell, removable hood, adjustable cuffs and four pockets are the kind of details that hold up on a ski hill or a wet hike. The Lzobxe is a lighter, water-repellent casual coat with a sherpa-style liner and a wider size run up to 3XL, but its own listing is vague on the liner and the hood, and it is built for light rain and commuting rather than real weather. Reviewers of the Summit rate it well overall; the Lzobxe has little track record to judge.

• Choose the Summit if you need genuine waterproofing, a zip-in liner and pockets for skiing, hiking or wet cold days.
• Choose the Lzobxe if you want a soft, casual winter coat in a larger size and only face light rain and wind.