Which is better for a home with pets?

The Tree Reindeer rug. It is listed as pet-friendly with a short pile that resists claw snags, and it is machine washable. The Burgundy Gold rug gives no pet or wash details.

Which is better for a dining room?

The Tree Reindeer rug, because spills can be blotted and the rug can go in the wash. The Burgundy Gold rug is better kept to low-mess decor spots like a bedroom or entryway.

Is the Burgundy Gold rug worth the extra money?

Only if you want its vintage burgundy-and-gold look. It costs about $40 more and has no wash or stain claims, so the price buys style, not easier care.

Which has more reliable ratings?

The Burgundy Gold rug, at 4.6 out of 5 from 34 ratings. The Tree Reindeer rug has a perfect 5 but from just 2 ratings.

Do either of them slip on hardwood?

Both list a non-slip backing. The Tree Reindeer rug calls it non-slip, and the Burgundy Gold rug lists a non-slip cotton sole.

Which comes in more sizes?

The Tree Reindeer rug, in nine sizes from 2'x3' to 9'x12'. The Burgundy Gold rug does not list its sizes.

Tree Reindeer Christmas Red Green Washable Rug vs Burgundy Gold Ornament Festive Holiday Rug

Buy the Tree Reindeer rug if you want a cheap, washable, pet-proof holiday rug for a busy room. Buy the Burgundy Gold Ornament rug if you want a dressier vintage look and will treat it as decor, not a workhorse. On November 5, 2026 the Tree Reindeer rug starts at $18.99 at The Home Depot, while the Burgundy Gold rug starts at $59.40 at Etsy.

Today the Tree Reindeer Christmas Red Green Washable Rug costs $40.41 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.