Which is better for a living room?

The Tree Reindeer Christmas, because you can pick 5'x7', 8'x10' or 9'x12' to fit the room. The PhoenixCrest comes only in 6'x9'.

Which is better for a hallway or entryway?

The PhoenixCrest 6'x9' suits a wide hallway or entry in one piece. The Tree Reindeer Christmas also comes in 2'x6' and 2'x8' runner sizes if you want a narrower fit.

Which is easier to clean?

Both are machine washable and stain-resistant. The Tree Reindeer Christmas states a gentle, cold cycle, which is the safer instruction to follow.

Is the Tree Reindeer Christmas worth the extra 52 cents?

Yes if you need a size other than 6'x9', a certified rug, or a pet-friendly pile. If 6'x9' fits and price is all that matters, the PhoenixCrest is cheaper.

Neither maker gives a warranty or wear rating. Flat woven rugs like the Tree Reindeer Christmas generally resist snagging better than tufted pile, so it is the safer bet in high-traffic or pet homes.

Do either shed or wrinkle?

Buyers of the Tree Reindeer Christmas report permanent wrinkles from vacuum packing. No buyer feedback is available for the PhoenixCrest.

Tree Reindeer Christmas Washable Rug vs PhoenixCrest Washable Christmas Runner Rug

Buy the Tree Reindeer Christmas rug if you want a true area rug in a size that fits a room; it comes in nine sizes up to 9'x12' and is flat woven at 0.24" thick. Buy the PhoenixCrest runner only if you need a 6'x9' holiday rug and nothing else. Prices are close: $39.99 at Amazon as of November 8, 2026 for the Tree Reindeer Christmas, and $39.47 at Kohl's as of November 8, 2026 for the PhoenixCrest.

Today the PhoenixCrest Washable Christmas Runner Rug costs $0.52 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.