Which is better for a living room?

The Garvee, if the room needs an 8x10. The Tree Reindeer tops out at 9x12 but costs more in that size. For a smaller seating area, the Tree Reindeer in 5'x7' is cheaper.

Neither maker gives a wear warranty. The Tree Reindeer's flat woven polyester is thin at 0.24", so expect it to show wear sooner in high traffic. The Garvee's thicker synthetic build is the safer bet for daily use.

Is the Tree Reindeer worth it at $18.99?

Yes for a seasonal accent. That is the lowest price since tracking began on October 30, 2026, down from $54.99. Treat it as a holiday item, not a year-round rug.

Can both go in a washing machine?

The Tree Reindeer is machine washable on a gentle, cold cycle. Garvee says washable but does not state a cycle, so check the label before washing.

Which is better with pets?

The Tree Reindeer. Its short pile resists claw snags and it is stain-resistant. Garvee does not describe pet suitability.

Which is cheaper per square foot?

The Garvee at about $1.12 per square foot in 8x10. The Tree Reindeer is about $1.90 per square foot at that size, though its small sizes cost less in total.

Tree Reindeer Christmas Red Green Washable Rug vs Garvee 8x10 Christmas Washable Area Rug

Buy the Tree Reindeer rug if you want a cheap, festive holiday rug you can machine wash after a party. Buy the Garvee 8x10 if you need to cover a large room and want the bigger size at a lower cost per square foot. As of November 5, 2026, the Tree Reindeer starts at $18.99 at The Home Depot, while the Garvee is $89.99 at Walmart. The Tree Reindeer comes in nine sizes; the Garvee comes in one.

Today the Tree Reindeer Christmas Red Green Washable Rug costs $71.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.