Which is better for a dining room?

The Tree Reindeer rug, if the table area is larger than 20 x 30 inches. It comes in sizes up to 9'x12' and is stain-resistant and washable. The Pinecone is too small to sit under a dining table.

The Pinecone's braided jute is dense and reversible, so it wears well in a low-traffic spot. The Tree Reindeer's polyester pile is thin and machine washing will wear it over time. Neither is a long-term heirloom.

Is the Tree Reindeer rug worth the extra $5?

Yes, for most shoppers. At $39.99 versus $34.99 as of November 8, 2026, you get a much larger size range, machine washing and stain resistance. The Pinecone only wins if you specifically want a small handmade jute piece.

Can I put the Pinecone rug in a washing machine?

No. Jute should be spot cleaned only; machine washing can break down the fibers. The Tree Reindeer rug is the one built for machine washing on a gentle cold cycle.

Which is better with pets?

The Tree Reindeer rug. Its short polyester pile resists claw snags, it is stain-resistant and it is machine washable. Jute is rougher and harder to clean.

Will the Tree Reindeer rug flatten out?

Buyers report permanent wrinkles from vacuum packing. The rug's size can hide some of them, but creases may not fully relax. Lying it flat in a warm room helps.

Tree Reindeer Christmas Washable Rug vs Homespice Pinecone Jute Braided Rug

Buy the Tree Reindeer Christmas rug if you want a festive red-green holiday rug in a real room size that you can machine wash. Buy the Homespice Pinecone Jute rug if you want a small, reversible, handmade accent piece with a woodland look. The Tree Reindeer rug is $39.99 at Amazon as of November 8, 2026, and the Pinecone is $34.99 at Braided-Rugs.com as of the same date. The Tree Reindeer rug has also sold as low as $18.99 on November 5, 2026, so its price moves a lot.

Today the Homespice Pinecone Jute Braided Rug costs $5.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.