Which is cheaper per sheet, Scott 1000 or Charmin Ultra Soft?

Scott 1000. At the November 8, 2026 prices, Scott's 36,000 sheets cost $6.49, about $0.00018 per sheet, versus about $0.0069 per sheet for Charmin's 1,344 sheets at $9.29.

Which is better for a low-flow or septic toilet?

Scott 1000. It is built with clog-free technology, dissolves 10x faster than a national brand soft and strong mega roll, and is 100% septic-safe. Charmin Ultra Soft is also labeled septic safe but is a thicker 2-ply sheet.

Is Charmin Ultra Soft worth the extra money?

If comfort is your priority, yes. You get a 2-ply ultra soft sheet with 2X absorbency and better tear resistance. If you care about cost per sheet and fewer roll changes, Scott 1000 wins.

Which pack lasts longer?

Scott 1000. Its 36 rolls hold 36,000 sheets, while Charmin's 6 Mega Rolls hold 1,344 sheets, so Scott lasts many times longer per pack.

Charmin Ultra Soft. It is a 2-ply ultra soft tissue with a smooth texture. Scott 1000 is a basic 1-ply tissue and is not marketed for softness.

Are either made from responsible sources?

Scott 1000 carries FSC third-party certification. Charmin Ultra Soft is listed as sourced from responsible forestry and contains no recycled content.

Scott 1000 Toilet Paper vs Charmin Ultra Soft Bath Tissue

Buy Scott 1000 if you want the lowest cost per sheet and clog-free performance in low-flow toilets. Buy Charmin Ultra Soft if comfort matters more than cost and you want a 2-ply sheet. On November 8, 2026, Scott 1000's 36 rolls cost $6.49 at shopthepapa.com, while Charmin Ultra Soft's 6 Mega Rolls cost $9.29 at rosauers.com. That works out to well under a cent per sheet for Scott and roughly seven-tenths of a cent per sheet for Charmin.

Today the Scott 1000 Toilet Paper costs $2.80 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.