Which has more cooking space?

The previous model lists 994 sq in total, split between 646 sq in primary and 348 sq in top grate. The current model's listing gives no area figures, so compare the two listings on Deal.ai if space is your deciding factor.

Is the current model worth the extra money?

Only if you will use WEBER CRAFTED inserts and the bigger sear zone. If you mainly grill burgers and chicken, the previous model's 994 sq in and 12,000 BTU sear burner cover it, so buy whichever is cheaper.

The current model has Weber's largest and hottest sear zone, so it sears more steaks at once. The previous model's 12,000 BTU Sear Zone burner is still strong for a single batch.

Do both run on propane?

Yes, both are liquid propane grills. The previous model's listing notes a 20 lb. tank is sold separately, so budget for a tank if you don't have one.

Which is more reliable?

The previous model has a long record: 4.6 out of 5 from 3,046 ratings. The current model is too new for that kind of track record, though it shares the same stainless steel build and 4-burner layout.

What accessories carry over?

Standard grates, covers and tools fit either grill. Only the current model takes WEBER CRAFTED drop-in inserts, which do not fit the previous model.

Weber Genesis S-435 Gas Grill vs Weber Genesis S-435 Gas Grill

Both are 4-burner stainless Genesis S-435 propane grills with a side burner, so the choice comes down to generation and price. The previous model is the known quantity: 994 sq in total cooking area, a 12,000 BTU sear zone, and a 4.6 rating from over 3,000 owners. The current model adds the WEBER CRAFTED frame for drop-in grillware and a larger sear zone, but no price was given for either grill here, so check both listings on Deal.ai before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.