Which is better for searing steaks?

The Genesis S-435. Its sear zone is rated 12,000 BTU and is Weber's largest, so it fits more steaks at once than the Genesis II S-435.

Can I use WEBER CRAFTED grillware on the Genesis II S-435?

No. The drop-in grillware needs the WEBER CRAFTED frame, which only the newer S-435 has.

Is the S-435 worth the extra money?

Yes if you plan to add grillware or sear for a crowd. If you just want four burners and a side burner, the Genesis II does the same job for less.

Do either come with a propane tank?

No. The S-435 lists a 20 lb tank as sold separately, and the Genesis II is also a propane grill without a tank included.

Both use stainless steel burners and a stainless finish, so life depends on care and cover. The S-435 is newer, so its parts will stay available longer.

How much counter space do they need?

Both are 48 in high and 27 in deep with the lid closed. The S-435 needs 63 in of height and 68.5 in of width with the lid open.

Weber Genesis S-435 Gas Grill vs Weber Genesis II S-435 Propane Grill

Both are 4-burner stainless Genesis grills with a side burner, a sear zone and about 994 square inches of total cooking area. The S-435 (previous model) is the newer design: it adds the WEBER CRAFTED frame for drop-in grillware and the larger sear zone, so it is the better pick for anyone who wants to expand the grill later. The Genesis II S-435 is the older generation and is the better buy only if it costs clearly less. Check the current price at each store before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.