StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
AllTravelTechClothesShoesJewelryHomeBeautyOutdoorsToys
This hour's deals
Allen Edmonds
Allen Edmonds Men's Fifth Avenue Oxford
−40%
Shoes · Allen Edmonds

The oxford that means business at the office

Allen Edmonds Men's Fifth Avenue Oxford

Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue oxford, a dress shoe staple for men who wear suits.

Deal score 5.5 · Good deal
$269.00$450.00 Allen Edmonds's regular price

You save $181.00 at Allen Edmonds

This deal was in an earlier drop. The store may have changed its price since.

Why it's a great deal

  • Allen Edmonds lists its regular price at $450.00: 40% off by its own figures
  • Rated 4.4 out of 5 by 2,800 buyers
  • Shoppers say the Fifth Avenue cap-toe has a classic, polished look that fits any office or client meeting Shoppers on Google Shopping
  • Allen Edmonds says its Oxfords use a traditional 360-degree bench welt for stability and longevity Allen Edmonds
Visit Allen Edmonds

Every store we checked

  • Allen EdmondsNew

    In stock

    $369.00Free shippingChecked Nov 16
    Visit Allen Edmonds
  • Sherman Brothers ShoesNew

    In stock

    $450.00Free shippingChecked Nov 16
    Visit Sherman Brothers Shoes
  • J. Men's ClothingNew

    In stock

    $450.00Free shippingChecked Nov 16
    Visit J. Men's Clothing
  • WhatnotNew

    Availability unknown

    $49.99Checked Nov 16
    Visit Whatnot
  • Books of DiscoveryNew

    Availability unknown

    $135.00Checked Nov 12
    Visit Books of Discovery
  • Sui Generis Designer ConsignmentNew

    Availability unknown

    $202.00Checked Nov 16
    Visit Sui Generis Designer Consignment
  • Sui Generis Designer ConsignmentPre-owned

    Availability unknown

    $202.00Checked Nov 13
    Visit Sui Generis Designer Consignment
  • PoshmarkPre-owned

    Availability unknown

    $228.00Checked Nov 16
    Visit Poshmark
  • PoshmarkNew

    Availability unknown

    $228.00Checked Nov 14
    Visit Poshmark
  • eBayNew

    Availability unknownShips from Singapore · duties may apply

    $231.55Checked Nov 14
    Visit eBay
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $369.00Free shippingChecked Nov 17
    Visit Amazon
  • RealryNew

    Availability unknown

    $369.00Checked Nov 14
    Visit Realry
  • Daniels ShoesNew

    Availability unknown

    $395.00Checked Nov 14
    Visit Daniels Shoes
  • holidayhillapartamenty.plNew

    Availability unknownShips from Poland · duties may apply

    $400.00Checked Nov 14
    Visit holidayhillapartamenty.pl
  • O'Connell's ClothingNew

    Availability unknown

    $425.00Checked Nov 14
    Visit O'Connell's Clothing
  • EditorialistNew

    Availability unknown

    $450.00Checked Nov 16
    Visit Editorialist
  • MensDesignerShoe.comNew

    Availability unknown

    $450.00Checked Nov 16
    Visit MensDesignerShoe.com
  • Daphne's Shoe BoutiqueNew

    Availability unknown

    $450.00Checked Nov 16
    Visit Daphne's Shoe Boutique
  • eBayPre-owned

    Availability unknown

    $134.99Checked Nov 4
    Visit eBay

Store links may earn us a commission.

Price history and every store's price →

Reading Allen Edmonds’s product page for the details…

About it

Vintage Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Oxford Shoes Mens 8.5 Brown Cap Toe Leather

Condition: Preowned Condition. Shows darkening to toe caps, heavy insole wear and fading, surface scuffs, top collar rubbing, and added Vibram half-soles with heel taps. Please see photos for details and measurements.

Brand: Allen Edmonds

Tag Size: 8 1/2 M

Color: Walnut light brown

Material: Genuine leather upper, leather lining, Vibram rubber and leather outsole

Fabric Type: Smooth calfskin leather

Pattern: Solid

Features: Perforated brogue cap toe, closed lace-up oxford balmoral construction, 360-degree Goodyear welt, custom cobbler Vibram rubber protective half soles, heel plates, leather lining

Notes: Style Fifth Avenue 5735, 8 1/2 M. Made in USA. Classic heritage dress shoe silhouette.

Daily Shipping | Bundle & Save | Questions? Message Us

Favorite our shop to see our latest finds first! Thank you for shopping with us!

Specs

Gender
Men's
Type
Oxford
Closure Style
Lace-up
Material
Leather
Leather Material
European calfskin leather, Vegetable-tanned leather
Occasion
Formal
Age Group
Adult
Department
Men's
Outsole Material
Leather
Season
Winter, Fall, Spring, Summer

About the Allen Edmonds Men's Fifth Avenue Oxford

The Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue is a cap-toe balmoral oxford in European calfskin with brogue detailing, a leather sole and a CustomCork insole that molds to the foot. It is one of Allen Edmonds' core dress shoes, made in the US and recraftable at the factory. It sits above glued department-store oxfords on leather, welt and recrafting, and below the brand's sleekest lasts on shape. Owners rate it well for build and fit once broken in.

Best forMen who need one dark suit shoe for work and weddingsBuyers who want a recraftable, long-life dress shoeNarrow or wide feet, thanks to multiple widthsAnyone replacing a worn-out department-store oxford
Pros
  • Classic cap-toe balmoral shape that suits suits and interviews
  • Full-grain European calfskin takes a polish well
  • CustomCork insole breaks in to the shape of your foot
  • Leather sole with a proper welt, so Allen Edmonds can recraft it
  • Sold in several widths, not just medium
Cons

More deals like this

  • All Allen Edmonds deals and products
  • All Allen Edmonds deals and prices
  • All Books of Discovery deals and prices
  • All Whatnot deals and prices
  • Early Black Friday Shoe Deals 2026

Price facts

  • This deal was $269.00 at Allen Edmonds on Oct 28.
  • Last seen at $49.99 at Whatnot on Nov 16.
  • That's the lowest price we've seen since Oct 28.
  • It's down $69.01 from $119.00 a week ago.
  • Since Oct 28 it has ranged from $49.99 to $450.00.
  • Checked at 16 stores.

Ask our agent about this deal

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

  • Stiff out of the box; expect a break-in period
  • Leather sole is slick on wet pavement until scuffed
  • Not a casual shoe; brogue cap toe reads formal
  • Needs shoe trees and regular polishing to hold up
  • What reviewers say

    • 4.4 / 52,800 ratings

    Rated 4.4 out of 5 across about 2,800 ratings, owners mostly praise the build and the fit once broken in. Complaints center on stiffness at first and on sizing being inconsistent between widths.

    What people mention
    • Break-inMixedOwners say the shoe is stiff at first and takes a few wears to soften.
    • Build qualityPraisedReviewers point to the leather, welt and stitching as the reason the shoe lasts.
    • FitMixedSome buyers find the width sizing inconsistent and recommend trying pairs on.
    • Sole gripCriticisedThe leather outsole is described as slippery on wet or smooth floors until it is scuffed.
    • ValueMixedBuyers like the shoe but say full price is steep and wait for markdowns.

    Questions and answers

    Is the Fifth Avenue worth it over a cheaper oxford?
    If you wear dress shoes several days a week, yes. The leather and welted construction let Allen Edmonds recraft the shoe instead of replacing it, which cheaper glued shoes cannot match.
    How does it fit compared to other Allen Edmonds shoes?
    It uses the 65 last, which runs long and narrow, so many buyers go down half a size from sneakers. Try your usual width first, then adjust.
    How long does the break-in take?
    Most owners report a week or two of wear before the calfskin and cork insole soften. Wear them indoors first to avoid blisters.
    Can the sole be replaced?
    Yes. The Goodyear-welted leather sole can be replaced through Allen Edmonds' recrafting service, which also refinishes the upper.
    What comes in the box?
    The pair of shoes and dust bags. Shoe trees and polish are sold separately and are worth adding.

    More from Allen Edmonds

    • A
      Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Cap-toe Oxford Dress Shoe
      Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Cap-toe Oxford Dress Shoe
    • A
      Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Oxford
      Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Oxford
    • A
      Allen Edmonds Tompkins Men's Boot
      Allen Edmonds Tompkins Men's Boot
    • A
      Allen Edmonds Park Avenue
      Allen Edmonds Park Avenue
    • A
      Allen Edmonds Windsor Plain Toe Derby
      Allen Edmonds Windsor Plain Toe Derby
    • A
      Allen Edmonds Windsor Men's Shoe
      Allen Edmonds Windsor Men's Shoe
    • A
      Allen Edmonds Park Cap Toe Boot
      Allen Edmonds Park Cap Toe Boot
    • A
      Allen Edmonds Windsor Derby Leather
      Allen Edmonds Windsor Derby Leather

    More men's oxford shoes

    • R
      Rush Men's by Gordon Rush Plain Toe Oxford
      Rush Men's by Gordon Rush Plain Toe Oxford
    • S
      Stacy Adams Hobson Cap Toe Oxford Men's Shoes
      Stacy Adams Hobson Cap Toe Oxford Men's Shoes
    • C
      Cole Haan Men's Go-To Wingtip Oxford
      Cole Haan Men's Go-To Wingtip Oxford
    • B
      BRUNO MARC Men s Fashion Tuxedo Oxford Shoes
      BRUNO MARC Men s Fashion Tuxedo Oxford Shoes
    • C
      Cole Haan Men's Harmon Grand Cap Toe Oxford Shoes
      Cole Haan Men's Harmon Grand Cap Toe Oxford Shoes
    • S
      Steve Madden Zyon Leather Cap Toe Oxford
      Steve Madden Zyon Leather Cap Toe Oxford
    • S
      Stacy Adams Dickinson Cap Toe Oxford
      Stacy Adams Dickinson Cap Toe Oxford
    • T
      Tommy Hilfiger Men's Hiday Oxford
      Tommy Hilfiger Men's Hiday Oxford