Is the PHOFAY eyeliner set actually waterproof?

The set is labeled waterproof and long-lasting. Pencil formulas hold up to tears and light moisture, but on oily lids or in humidity they can smudge without a primer or setting powder.

How big are the pencils?

Each pencil holds 0.8g of product, and the set includes eight. That is smaller than a standard full-size eyeliner, so the set is better for sampling colors than for daily long-term use.

Can I use these on the waterline?

Yes. The brand suggests swiping across the waterline for a defined look. Matte pencils can tug there, so warm the tip on the back of your hand first.

Are the shades matte or shimmery?

The set is described as matte. That makes it good for graphic lines and smoky washes without glitter fallout.

Do I need a primer with this set?

Not always, but a primer or a light setting powder helps on oily lids, where pencil liners tend to fade or transfer.

What is the microtip for?

The microtip draws precise thin lines for graphic, chromatic looks. Use the side of the tip for broader washes and smudging.

Where is the PHOFAY Waterproof Colorful Eyeliner Set cheapest?

At Deal.ai, for $20.12, as of our latest check.

PHOFAY Waterproof Colorful Eyeliner Set

Sold and shipped by Deal.ai

$20.12+ $5.49 shipping

Style: 8Color Set

Arrives about Nov 14–23, from a US warehouse

No returns for change of mind. If it arrives damaged or isn't what you ordered, or never arrives, report it within 30 days and we refund you in full.

Ask our agent about this product

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Price facts

Last seen at $20.12 at Deal.ai on Nov 10.

Our take on the PHOFAY Waterproof Colorful Eyeliner Set

The PHOFAY Waterproof Colorful Eyeliner Set is an eight-piece pencil set with a matte finish and a microtip for fine lines. Each pencil weighs 0.8g, so the set is built for trying many shades rather than committing to one. The waterproof, long-wear claim suits waterline and graphic looks, and the smudgeable formula works for smoky washes. It competes with single full-size liners on variety, not on per-shade volume, and pencil formulas like this usually need a primer on oily lids.