Terra & Sky Plus High-Rise Pull-On Jeggings vs Avenue Butter Denim Pull-On Jean

The Terra & Sky jeggings are the safer buy for most shoppers: a 4.5 rating from over 1,100 owners beats Avenue's 3.9 from 100, and the belt loops and classic jeans detailing make them easier to dress up. The Avenue Butter Denim is the better pick if you want a true petite or tall inseam, since it comes in 26-inch and 33-inch lengths while Terra & Sky is sold in one length. Both are pull-on high-rise skinnies with stretch, so the decision comes down to length options and fit consistency, and Avenue's own fit tip warns its jeans run small.

• Choose the Terra & Sky jeggings if you want a proven, well-rated pull-on skinny with belt loops and a classic jeans look in a standard length.
• Choose the Avenue Butter Denim if you are petite or tall and need a 26-inch or 33-inch inseam, or you want a wide elastic comfort waistband and functional back pockets.