Which is warmer, the MEICHEN or the Carhartt A18?

Both are acrylic knits of similar weight, so warmth is close. The Carhartt's rib knit is denser and its wider fit lets you pull the cuff lower over the ears.

Is the Carhartt A18 worth $9 more than the MEICHEN?

If you want a hat that keeps its shape and fits larger heads, yes. If you just need a cheap warm hat, the MEICHEN at $6.69 does the job.

Will the MEICHEN fit a large head?

It is listed at 54–58 cm, so it will be tight above that. The Carhartt A18 goes to 63 cm.

Can I machine wash either beanie?

Carhartt says hand wash only for the A18. The MEICHEN listing gives no care instructions, so hand washing is the safe choice for both.

Which has dropped in price recently?

The Carhartt A18 went from $19.99 on October 31, 2026 to $15.99 on November 4, 2026. No price history is given for the MEICHEN.

MEICHEN Unisex Beanie Winter Knitted Cuffed Soft Warm Hat for Men/Women Ski Watch Cap vs Carhartt A18 Beanie

Buy the Carhartt A18 if you want a beanie that holds its shape, fits heads up to 63 cm, and carries a brand patch that has been on the same design since 1987. Buy the MEICHEN if you want the cheapest warm hat and don't care about brand or fit range. The Carhartt is $15.99 at eBay as of November 4, 2026, against $6.69 at Walmart for the MEICHEN — about $9.30 more.

Today the MEICHEN Unisex Beanie Winter Knitted Cuffed Soft Warm Hat for Men/Women Ski Watch Cap costs $9.30 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent