CiTree Cigar Travel Ashtray vs Stinky Floor Ashtray
These are two different jobs. The CiTree is a pocket-sized aluminum travel ashtray that holds one cigar up to 60 ring gauge and goes in a bag or a cup holder. The Stinky is a 24-inch floor-standing steel ashtray with a 3-inch deep bowl, four stirrups and an accessory tray, meant to stay put on a patio or in a den. Buyers of the Stinky praise its sturdy, classy look and gift appeal; the CiTree is a simple, light, dishwasher-safe metal case with no lid, so it is a carry piece rather than a room piece.
- Choose the CiTree if you smoke away from home and want one cigar's worth of ash containment that fits in a pocket or glovebox.
- Choose the Stinky if you smoke at home or outdoors in one spot and want a stable floor ashtray that holds several cigars and keeps ash from blowing around.
Prices
- CiTree Cigar Travel Ashtray: $15.99 at Amazon (checked today)
- Stinky Floor Ashtray: $119.99 at Wayfair (last seen Nov 20)
- Difference: the CiTree Cigar Travel Ashtray is $104.00 cheaper than the Stinky Floor Ashtray at the latest prices (Nov 20 and Nov 21)
