StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Stinky Floor Ashtray vs Club Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray

Buy the Stinky Floor Ashtray if you smoke standing up, on a porch, or in a garage and want a heavy, stable piece that will not tip or skid. Buy the Club Macanudo Square if you want a light, dishwasher-safe table ashtray for a patio or balcony. The Stinky is the sturdier, more permanent object; the Macanudo is the easier one to move, clean and store. Owners of the Stinky consistently call it sturdy and classy-looking, while the Macanudo's melamine build is the trade-off for its low weight.

  • Choose the Stinky Floor Ashtray if you want a floor-standing, wind-resistant bowl with a wide base that stays put outdoors.
  • Choose the Club Macanudo Square if you want a light, square table ashtray you can rinse or put in the dishwasher.

Prices

  • Stinky Floor Ashtray: $119.99 at Wayfair (last seen Nov 20)
  • Club Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray: $19.95 at Walmart (checked today)
  • Difference: the Club Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray is $100.04 cheaper than the Stinky Floor Ashtray at the latest prices (Nov 20 and Nov 21)
Stinky
Stinky Floor Ashtray

Stinky Floor Ashtray
5(2 ratings)
$119.99at WayfairChecked 12 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Wayfair
Pros
  • Heavy metal body with a wide base that resists tipping
  • 3 in deep bowl keeps ash and stubs contained in wind
  • Four stirrups hold cigars apart
  • Removable bowl and carry handle make emptying easy
  • Owners describe it as sturdy and classy-looking
Cons
  • Heavy and awkward to relocate
  • No lid, so rain can collect in the bowl
  • Hand wash only
  • Takes up floor space
Club Macanudo
Club Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray

Club Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray

$19.95at WalmartChecked 1 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Walmart
Pros
  • Light enough to move between table and shelf
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Square 7.5 in footprint suits a patio table
  • Club Macanudo logo finish
Cons
  • Melamine can crack or chip if dropped
  • Shallow open tray lets ash blow out
  • No individual cigar rests
  • Light weight means it can slide or tip in wind

What separates them

Stinky Floor AshtrayClub Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray
MountingFloor-standing, 24 in tallTabletop, 2 in tall
MaterialMetalMelamine
Weight5.95 lb, wide base resists tip-overs1.5 lb, light and easy to move
Bowl depth3 in deep bowl holds ashes, bands and stubsShallow square tray
Wind resistanceDeep bowl design keeps ash from blowing outOpen square tray, exposed to wind
CleaningRemovable bowl, hand washDishwasher safe
PortabilityCarry handle, but heavy to move aroundLight enough to carry one-handed
Cigar capacityFour stirrupsSingle square tray, no individual rests

Price history

$125.99$19.95
Nov 7Nov 21
  • Stinky Floor Ashtray: lowest $119.99 on Nov 20 at Wayfair.
  • Club Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray: lowest $19.95 on Nov 7 at Walmart; $19.95 on Nov 21.

Prices at every store

Stinky Floor Ashtray

  • Northwoods HumidorsNew

    In stock

    $139.99Free shippingChecked 12 h ago
    Visit Northwoods Humidors
  • cigarinc.comNew

    In stock

    $158.09Checked 12 h ago
    Visit cigarinc.com
  • WayfairNew

    Availability unknown

    $119.99Checked 12 h ago
    Visit Wayfair
  • The CigarboxNew

    Availability unknown

    $155.00Checked 12 h ago
    Visit The Cigarbox
All 12 stores and price history →

Club Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray

  • WalmartNew

    In stockSold by Mikes Cigars Inc

    $19.95Free shippingChecked 1 h ago
    Visit Walmart
  • EtsyPre-owned

    In stock

    $19.99Checked Nov 10
    Visit Etsy

Also available at

  • WalmartCheck price at Walmart
All 2 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecStinky Floor AshtrayClub Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray
ColorChocolate BrownBlack
MaterialMetalMelamine
ShapeOtherSquare
Weight5.95 lbs1.5 lb
PatternSolid color—
Lid TypeWithout Lid—
StyleArt Deco—
Cig Capacity4—
Typical UsersSmokers—
Diameter—7.5 in
Rec. use—Table
Rec location—Outdoor
Show all 16 specsShow fewer specs
SpecStinky Floor AshtrayClub Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray
Brand—Macanudo
Count—1
Type—Ashtray
size—7.5" x 7.5" x 2"

Questions and answers

Which is better for a windy porch?
The Stinky. Its 3 in deep bowl and 5.95 lb metal base keep ash in and the ashtray upright. The Macanudo's open square tray and 1.5 lb weight work against it in wind.
Which is easier to clean?
The Macanudo, which is dishwasher safe. The Stinky's bowl lifts out for hand washing, which takes more effort but keeps ash out of the rest of the unit.
Which lasts longer?
The Stinky's metal body should outlast melamine, which can chip or crack if dropped. The Macanudo is durable for its material but not built to be knocked around.
Can I use the Macanudo on the floor?
You can, but it is designed as a table ashtray. It sits only 2 in tall, so you would be bending down to it, and it is light enough to be kicked or blown over.
Is the Stinky worth stepping up to?
If you smoke outdoors regularly and want one ashtray that stays put, yes. If you only need something for a table now and then, the Macanudo covers that with less bulk.
Does either hold more than one cigar?
The Stinky has four stirrups for resting cigars separately. The Macanudo is a single square tray with no individual rests.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Stinky Floor Ashtray vs TAG Pryce Cigar Ashtray
  • Club Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray vs TAG Pryce Cigar Ashtray
  • Xikar Ashtray vs Club Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray
  • La Aroma de Cuba Ceramic 4-Finger Ashtray vs Club Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray
  • CiTree Cigar Travel Ashtray, Metal (Black) vs Stinky Floor Ashtray
  • Prestige Smokin Quadrangle Cigar Ashtray Polished Stainless Steel vs Club Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray
  • Club Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray vs Craftsman's Bench Polyresin Cigar Ashtray - Natural Leaf
  • Xikar Ceramic Ashtray vs Club Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best cigar ashtrays