Garvee 85 Inch Chenille Sofa vs Better Homes & Gardens Lillian Tufted Sofa

The Garvee is the better pick for a large living room where people stretch out and lounge. Its 85-inch width, deep seat and three-level adjustable armrests that fold flat into a daybed give it far more usable lounging room than the Lillian. The Lillian is a smaller, lighter, mid-century channel-tufted piece with a solid wood frame and sinuous spring seats, and it suits tight spaces and a tidier look. Owners of both report the usual budget-sofa trade-offs: the Garvee's chenille is soft but the 30-day warranty is short, and the Lillian's linen-look polyester and woven rope back need care with heavy daily use.

• Choose the Garvee if you have the floor space and want a wide, deep seat that converts to a daybed for movie nights and naps.
• Choose the Lillian if you want a compact, lighter mid-century sofa with a solid wood frame that fits a small room or apartment.