Paul Fredrick Non-Iron Cotton Dress Shirt vs Paul Fredrick Non-Iron Check Dress Shirt

These are the same Paul Fredrick shirt in the same non-iron poplin, classic fit and button-down collar, so the choice comes down to pattern. The solid navy is the safer, more versatile shirt and carries a slightly higher rating from more owners. The blue check is the one to pick if you want visible pattern and already own plain blues. Owners of both report a good fit, crisp non-iron finish and solid construction; the recurring gripe on both is tight buttonholes and buttons that can be oversized for them.

• Choose the solid navy if you want one shirt that works under a suit, with a blazer or on its own, and you prefer the cleaner look with contrast inside both the neckband and cuffs.
• Choose the blue check if you want pattern that reads well without a tie and you already have plain blue shirts covered.