Pink Penguin Warmies vs Ms. Rachel Tonie
These are not substitutes. The Pink Penguin Warmies is a microwaveable plush for warmth, comfort and lavender scent; the Ms. Rachel Tonie is a 50-minute audio figurine that only works with a Toniebox speaker. Buy the Warmies for a cozy, screen-free gift; buy the Tonie only if the child already has a Toniebox. On November 3, 2026, the Warmies was $22.49 at Ben Franklin and the Tonie $19.94 at Amazon, so the Tonie is cheaper but needs a separate speaker to do anything.
Today the Ms. Rachel Tonie costs $2.55 less at its best price.
Ask our shopping agent
Pink Penguin Warmies
4.8$22.49at Ben FranklinObserved Nov 2, 2026, 4:46 PM
Choose the Pink Penguin Warmies if you want a self-contained, all-ages comfort gift that heats in 90 seconds and needs no other device.
Pros
- Heats in 90 seconds and stays warm for hours
- Real dried French lavender adds aromatherapy
- Safe for all ages and doubles as a weighted comfort toy
- Freezer option gives cooling relief
Cons
- No removable or washable cover; wipe clean only
- Microwave required, so not usable away from a kitchen
- No auto shutoff or leakage protection
What separates them
| Pink Penguin Warmies | Ms. Rachel Tonie | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Microwaveable plush with millet and lavender filling | Audio figurine that plays through a Toniebox |
| Works on its own | Yes, no accessories needed | No, requires a Toniebox speaker sold separately |
| Age range | All ages | 1+ |
| Heat or cold use | 90 seconds in microwave; 2-3 hours in freezer | None |
| Content | Warmth and lavender scent only | 50 minutes of songs and learning content |
| Care | Wipe clean; cover not removable or washable | Wipe the figurine; no washing |
| Size and weight | About 10-12 inches tall, 2 lbs | 7 x 5 x 3 cm, light plastic |
| Price on November 3, 2026 |
Price history
- Pink Penguin Warmies: lowest $22.49 on Nov 2 at Ben Franklin.
- Ms. Rachel Tonie: lowest $19.94 on Nov 2 at Amazon.
Prices at every store
Pink Penguin Warmies
- KUBIOSTUDIOSNew
In stockReturn policy
$26.95Observed Nov 2, 2026, 4:45 PM - Ben FranklinNew
Availability unknown
$22.49Observed Nov 2, 2026, 4:46 PM - Courtney's Candles & CreationsNew
Availability unknown
$24.95Observed Nov 2, 2026, 4:46 PM - eBayNew
Availability unknown
$24.95Observed Nov 2, 2026, 4:46 PM
Also available at
- Warmies USACheck price at Warmies USA
- ZoroCheck price at Zoro
- Warmies USA WholesaleCheck price at Warmies USA Wholesale
Specs compared
| Spec | Pink Penguin Warmies | Ms. Rachel Tonie |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Polyester | PVC plastic, magnet, RFID tag |
| Dimensions | 10 x 5 x 5 inches | 7 x 5 x 3 cm |
| Product dimensions | 25.4 x 12.7 x 12.7 centimetres | — |
| Item weight | 649 g | — |
| Colour | White, Pink | — |
| Special features | Microwaveable | — |
| Microwave heating time | 90 seconds | — |
| Height | About 10 - 12 inches tall | — |
| Filling | specially treated millet grains and dried laven… | — |
| Age range | All Ages | — |
| Freezer chill time |
Questions and answers
- Which is better for a 1-year-old?
- The Tonie is rated 1+ and is built for toddlers, but it only works with a Toniebox. The Warmies is safe for all ages and works alone, so it is the simpler first gift.
- Is the Tonie worth it without a Toniebox?
- No. The figurine plays nothing on its own. Budget for a Toniebox before buying the $19.94 Tonie.
- Which lasts longer?
- The Tonie is a solid PVC figurine with no wear parts and should outlast a plush. The Warmies is fabric and filling, wiped clean only, and its lavender scent fades.
- Can the Warmies be washed?
- No. The cover is not removable or washable; wipe it clean. The Tonie is also wipe-clean only.
- Which is cheaper on November 3, 2026?
- The Tonie at $19.94 at Amazon, versus $22.49 at Ben Franklin for the Warmies. The Tonie's total cost is higher once you add a Toniebox.
More comparisons
- Hot Wheels Set of 8 Basic Toy Cars & Trucks in 1:64 Scale Including 1 Exclusive Car vs Pink Penguin Warmies
- Pink Penguin Warmies vs Peekaboo Learning Barnyard Playset
- Crayola Color Wonder Magic Light Brush Featuring Ms. Rachel vs Pink Penguin Warmies
- Crayola Color Wonder Magic Light Brush Featuring Ms. Rachel vs Ms. Rachel Tonie
- Hot Wheels Mystery Models Surprise Toy Car or Truck in 1:64 Scale vs Pink Penguin Warmies
- Hot Wheels Set of 8 Basic Toy Cars & Trucks in 1:64 Scale Including 1 Exclusive Car vs Ms. Rachel Tonie
