Crayola Color Wonder Magic Light Brush Featuring Ms. Rachel vs Ms. Rachel Tonie
These are different kinds of toy, so the choice comes down to the child. Pick the Crayola Magic Light Brush for a 3-year-old who likes to paint and a parent who wants no mess. Pick the Ms. Rachel Tonie for a 1- to 3-year-old who already has a Toniebox and loves her songs. The Tonie is far cheaper at $19.94 at Amazon as of November 3, 2026, but it needs a Toniebox, which sells separately.
Ask our shopping agent
Crayola Color Wonder Magic Light Brush Featuring Ms. Rachel
4.3Choose the Crayola Color Wonder Magic Light Brush if your child is 3 or older, wants to paint, and you want clear paint that only shows on Color Wonder paper.
Pros
- Paint stays off skin, clothing and walls
- Brush lights up to show the color, since the paint is clear
- Works for ages 3 and up with no screen
- Large rating base of 2,284
Cons
- Needs Color Wonder paper, which runs out
- Only one brush in the box
- Not suitable under age 3
What separates them
| Crayola Color Wonder Magic Light Brush Featuring Ms. Rachel | Ms. Rachel Tonie | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Not stated in the listing data | $19.94 at Amazon as of November 3, 2026 |
| Recommended age | 3 years and up | 1 year and up |
| What it is | Mess-free painting kit with a light-up brush | Audio figurine that plays 50 minutes of songs and lessons |
| Extra equipment needed | None beyond Color Wonder paper | Requires a Toniebox speaker, sold separately |
| Hands-on vs. listening | Child paints and creates | Child listens and sings along |
| Content | Open-ended painting with clear paints | Fixed 50-minute track list: Old MacDonald, Itsy Bitsy Spider, The Phonics Song, Big Feelings |
| Ratings | 4.3 out of 5 from 2,284 ratings | 5 out of 5 from 214 ratings |
Price history
- Crayola Color Wonder Magic Light Brush Featuring Ms. Rachel: lowest $17.69 on Oct 30 at Amazon.
- Ms. Rachel Tonie: lowest $19.94 on Nov 2 at Amazon.
Prices at every store
Crayola Color Wonder Magic Light Brush Featuring Ms. Rachel
- WalmartCheck price at Walmart
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- Bed Bath & BeyondCheck price at Bed Bath & Beyond
Ms. Rachel Tonie
- TargetNew
In stock
$19.99+ $5.99 shippingObserved Nov 2, 2026, 5:00 PM - AmazonNew
Availability unknown
$19.94Observed Nov 2, 2026, 5:00 PM
Also available at
- us.tonies.comCheck price at us.tonies.com
- Fantasy Island ToysCheck price at Fantasy Island Toys
- FAO SchwarzCheck price at FAO Schwarz
Specs compared
| Spec | Crayola Color Wonder Magic Light Brush Featuring Ms. Rachel | Ms. Rachel Tonie |
|---|---|---|
| Art & craft kit type | Art Kits | — |
| Age group | Child, Toddler | — |
| Age range | 3 Years & Up | — |
| Skill level | Beginner | — |
| Items included | Brush | — |
| Brand | Crayola | — |
| Theme | Multi-theme | — |
| Color | Blue | — |
| Minimum recommended age | 3 years | — |
| Maximum recommended age | 99 | — |
| Occasion |
Questions and answers
- Which is better for a 2-year-old?
- The Ms. Rachel Tonie. It is rated for age 1 and up, while the Crayola brush is for ages 3 and up.
- Do I need to buy anything else?
- Yes, for both. The Tonie needs a Toniebox speaker, sold separately. The Crayola brush needs Color Wonder paper.
- Which lasts longer?
- The Tonie, since it has no consumables. The Crayola kit runs out of Color Wonder paper and paint over time.
- Is the Tonie worth the extra cost?
- It is the cheaper item at $19.94 at Amazon as of November 3, 2026, but only if you already own a Toniebox. Otherwise add the box's price.
- Will the Crayola paint stain clothes?
- No. Color Wonder paint is clear and only shows on Color Wonder paper, not on skin, clothing or walls.
- Which has better ratings?
- The Tonie rates 5 out of 5 from 214 ratings. The Crayola brush rates 4.3 out of 5 from 2,284 ratings.
More comparisons
- Crayola Color Wonder Magic Light Brush Featuring Ms. Rachel vs Pink Penguin Warmies
- Pink Penguin Warmies vs Ms. Rachel Tonie
- Hot Wheels Set of 8 Basic Toy Cars & Trucks in 1:64 Scale Including 1 Exclusive Car vs Crayola Color Wonder Magic Light Brush Featuring Ms. Rachel
- Hot Wheels Set of 8 Basic Toy Cars & Trucks in 1:64 Scale Including 1 Exclusive Car vs Ms. Rachel Tonie
