Rubber Turkey Duck vs Rubber Duckies Yellow Classic
Buy the Rubber Turkey Duck if you want a floating, holiday-themed duck that can carry a custom imprint. Buy the Schylling Yellow Classic if you want a plain yellow bath duck for a young child at a low price. The Schylling duck's lowest recent daily price was $4.99 on October 29, 2026, and its highest was $8.99 on November 1, 2026. No current price was given for the Rubber Turkey Duck.
Ask our shopping agent
Rubber Turkey Duck
4.9Choose the Rubber Turkey Duck if you want a weighted duck that floats upright, a Thanksgiving decoration, or a duck you can screen print with a logo on the belly.
- Floats right side up thanks to the weighted bottom
- Lead free and phthalate free
- Can be screen printed with a logo on the belly
- Fits Thanksgiving decor and holiday events
- Not for children under 3 without supervision
- Only one duck per order
- Brown turkey look is seasonal, not a year-round bath toy
What separates them
| Rubber Turkey Duck | Rubber Duckies Yellow Classic | |
|---|---|---|
| Theme | Thanksgiving turkey styling, brown with orange and black markings | Classic plain yellow duck |
| Floating | Round weight at the bottom keeps it upright in water | Floats but does not stay upright; has holes in the bottom |
| Recommended age | 3 and above, with supervision under 3 | 1 to 6 |
| Custom imprint | Screen print on the belly, about 1 inch wide | No imprint option listed |
| Safety claims | Lead free and phthalate free | BPA free |
| Sound | Not stated | Does not squeak |
| Pack count | Sold as a single bulk duck | 12 pieces |
| Size |
Price history
- Rubber Turkey Duck: lowest $4.20 on Oct 29 at Top-Hotel Supply, Inc..
- Rubber Duckies Yellow Classic: lowest $4.99 on Oct 29 at Lucky Duck Toys; $8.99 on Nov 1.
Prices at every store
Rubber Turkey Duck
- DUCKY CITYCheck price at DUCKY CITY
- Top-Hotel Supply, Inc.Check price at Top-Hotel Supply, Inc.
Rubber Duckies Yellow Classic
- Learning Express Toys & Gifts - Newton MACheck price at Learning Express Toys & Gifts - Newton MA
- ZurchersCheck price at Zurchers
- Piccolo Mondo ToysCheck price at Piccolo Mondo Toys
Specs compared
| Spec | Rubber Turkey Duck | Rubber Duckies Yellow Classic |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Duck | Rubber duck |
| Size | 3"L x 4"W x 3 3/4"H | All-sizes |
| Material | Rubber | — |
| Item Size | 3 1/2"L x 3.0"W x 3 1/2"H | — |
| Packaging | Bulk | — |
| Imprint Location | Belly | — |
| Imprint Method | Screen Print | — |
| Imprint Area | 1"W x 3/8"H | — |
| Colors | Brown w/ Orange and Black Markings | — |
| Recommended For Ages | — | 1 to 6. |
| Brand |
What reviewers say
Rubber Turkey Duck
Rated 4.9 out of 5 from 10 ratings. Buyers are few but very positive, and the floating, festive design is the usual reason.
- Floats upright in water
- Festive Thanksgiving look
- Feels sturdy for a small rubber toy
- Bulk packaging, not gift-ready
- Smaller than some expected
Rubber Duckies Yellow Classic
Owner feedback on this style of Schylling duck is mixed. People like the classic look and the low price per duck, but many complain that the bottom holes trap water and the ducks stop floating upright.
- Classic look kids enjoy
- Good value in a 12-pack
- Small size suits toddlers
Questions and answers
- Which duck is better for a baby or toddler?
- The Schylling Yellow Classic, which is rated for ages 1 to 6. The Rubber Turkey Duck is rated for age 3 and up, with supervision under 3.
- Which one floats better in the bath?
- The Rubber Turkey Duck. Its round bottom weight keeps it upright. The Schylling duck floats but tips over and has holes in the bottom.
- Can I put a company logo on either duck?
- Only on the Rubber Turkey Duck, which takes a screen print on the belly about 1 inch wide. The Schylling duck has no imprint option.
- Is the Schylling duck worth the extra over its low price?
- Its recent daily prices ran from $4.99 to $8.99, so check the current price before buying. At the low end it is a cheap 12-pack of basic bath ducks.
- Which is better for a Thanksgiving table or gift shop?
- The Rubber Turkey Duck. Its turkey markings and imprint option suit holiday decor and branded giveaways.