Eastland Women's Classic Penny Loafer vs Eastland Classic II Penny Loafer

Both are Eastland penny loafers in polished leather with OrthoLite insoles, so the choice comes down to fit and finish. The Classic II adds a slightly taller block heel, a moc toe with penny slot, and comes in wide widths, which suits women who need room across the forefoot. The Classic Penny Loafer is the simpler, lighter, hand-sewn one-piece build with a lower 7/8-inch heel and a round toe, and owners say it needs little break-in. Buy the Classic II if you want a wide fit or a bit more heel; buy the Classic Penny Loafer if you want the lighter, more flexible everyday shoe.

• Choose the Classic Penny Loafer if you want a lighter, lower-heeled loafer with a flexible hand-sewn one-piece leather build and a round toe.
• Choose the Classic II Penny Loafer if you need a wide width, prefer a 1-inch block heel, or want the classic moc-toe penny-slot look.