Which is better for standing all day?

The Sawgrass is flat with a foam footbed, which suits long stretches on your feet. The Classic II has a 1-inch block heel and a cork and OrthoLite footbed, which some shoppers find more supportive but is less flat.

Is the Classic II worth the extra money?

It costs $114.99 versus $47.99 for the Sawgrass as of November 7, 2026. You pay about $67 more for a block heel, a cork and OrthoLite footbed, and a wide width option.

Which has a wider fit?

The Classic II is listed in wide width. The Sawgrass is listed in medium width only, so shoppers who need a wide fit should lean toward the Classic II.

The Classic II's 1-inch block heel and plain penny-loafer front read dressier. The Sawgrass is flat with a chain-link vamp detail, which leans casual.

Which comes in more colors?

The Classic II is listed in Blue and Natural. The Sawgrass is listed in Black only.

Which is easier to find on sale?

The Sawgrass is priced new at 8 stores and the Classic II at 3 as of November 7, 2026. More stores means more prices to compare for the Sawgrass.

Eastland Sawgrass Women's Loafers vs Eastland Classic II Penny Loafer

Buy the Sawgrass if you want a flat, inexpensive slip-on for casual wear. Buy the Classic II Penny Loafer if you want a leather loafer with a 1-inch block heel and a cork and OrthoLite footbed. The Sawgrass is $47.99 at Walmart as of November 7, 2026, and the Classic II is $114.99 at Rack Room Shoes as of the same date. The Sawgrass costs about $67 less and is sold by more stores.

Today the Eastland Sawgrass Women's Loafers costs $67.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.