Eastland Women's Classic Penny Loafer vs Eastland Classic II Loafers

Both are Eastland penny loafers in leather with rubber soles, but the Classic Penny Loafer is the better-built of the two. It uses hand-sewn one-piece moccasin construction and an OrthoLite moisture-wicking insole, and owners report little to no break-in. The Classic II is the older, plainer version with a basic cushioned insole and a 3.6 out of 5 rating from 22 ratings, which is middling. Buy the Classic Penny Loafer unless you specifically want the Classic II's look or find it in your size.

• Choose the Classic Penny Loafer if you want the more comfortable, better-made loafer for all-day wear at work or while traveling.
• Choose the Classic II if you prefer its simpler stitched look and want a basic leather slip-on.