Are these the same shoe?

Yes. Both are the Eastland Classic II women's penny loafer with a leather upper and slip-on fit. The difference is the listing: colorway, width, heel spec and price.

Product A at $39.99 at eBay as of November 7, 2026. Product B is $114.99 at Rack Room Shoes on the same date.

Which is better for wide feet?

Product B, which lists a wide width option. Product A is listed in standard width only.

Is the more expensive one worth it?

Only if you need the wide fit, the blue or natural color, or the 1-inch block heel. For the standard brown flat, the $39.99 pair is the same shoe for less.

Which has a more supportive insole?

Product B lists a cork and Ortholite insole, which generally gives more arch support than the plain cushioned insole on Product A.

Does either have a leather lining?

Product B lists a synthetic lining. Product A's listing does not specify a lining material.

Eastland Classic II Loafers vs Eastland Classic II Penny Loafer

Both are the same Eastland Classic II penny loafer, so the real choice is price and fit. Product A is the better buy at $39.99 at eBay as of November 7, 2026, versus $114.99 at Rack Room Shoes for Product B. Choose B only if you need the wide width, the blue or natural colorway, or the 1-inch block heel and want to buy from a full-price retailer.

Today the Eastland Classic II Loafers costs $75.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.