Which is better for all-day standing?

The Sawgrass has a memory foam footbed and a cotton lining, which points to more cushioning. The Classic II has a cushioned insole but no memory foam listed.

The Classic II. It was $39.99 at eBay as of November 7, 2026, against $47.99 at Walmart for the Sawgrass.

Which looks dressier?

The Sawgrass, with its gunmetal chain-link vamp. The Classic II is a plain penny loafer with white stitching.

Do they come in the same colors?

No. The Sawgrass is listed in black only. The Classic II is listed in brown leather.

Both use a leather upper and rubber outsole, so wear should be similar. The Sawgrass adds a cotton lining, which can reduce rubbing inside the shoe.

Is the Sawgrass worth the extra money?

If you want the chain detail and memory foam footbed, yes. If you just want a basic leather penny loafer, the Classic II saves you money.

Eastland Sawgrass Women's Loafers vs Eastland Classic II Loafers

Both are Eastland leather slip-on loafers, so the choice comes down to style and price. The Sawgrass has a chain-link vamp and a memory foam footbed; the Classic II is the plainer penny loafer with a cushioned insole. The Classic II is cheaper at the latest check: $39.99 at eBay versus $47.99 at Walmart for the Sawgrass, both as of November 7, 2026.

Today the Eastland Classic II Loafers costs $8.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.