Black FridayDealsBuying guidesBrandsStoresTermsPrivacydeal.ai apps

© Deal.ai Inc.

Deal.ai › Compare

30g Protein Shake - Vanilla Bean vs Chocolate Protein Shakes

Buy the Quest Chocolate Protein Shakes if price and flavor matter most: $12.99 for a 4-pack at Quest Nutrition as of November 4, 2026, versus $29.94 for Orgain's 4-pack at Amazon. Buy the Orgain 30g Protein Shake if you want a vanilla option with no sucralose and no carrageenan, and you are willing to pay more than double. Both deliver 30g of protein per 11 fl oz carton with about 1g of sugar.

Today the Chocolate Protein Shakes costs $16.95 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

3
30g Protein Shake - Vanilla Bean

30g Protein Shake - Vanilla Bean

4.8· 410 ratings
$29.94at AmazonObserved at 3:52 PM
Visit store

Choose the Orgain 30g Protein Shake if you want a vanilla shake with no artificial sweeteners, no carrageenan and no added hormones, and the higher price is acceptable.

Pros
  • 30g of milk protein per carton with just 1g of sugar
  • No sucralose, no carrageenan, no added hormones
  • Gluten free and kosher dairy
  • 160 calories per serving, the lower of the two
Cons
  • $29.94 for 4 cartons is more than double the Quest price
  • Only vanilla bean flavor in this version
  • 350mg sodium per carton, higher than Quest
  • No calcium figure published
C
Chocolate Protein Shakes

Chocolate Protein Shakes

$12.99at Quest NutritionObserved at 4:44 PM
Visit store

Choose the Quest Chocolate Protein Shakes if you want the lowest price per shake and a chocolate flavor, and sucralose is fine for you.

Pros
  • $12.99 for 4 cartons at Quest Nutrition as of November 4, 2026
  • 30g of protein with 1g of sugar and 4g of carbs
  • 700mg calcium and 310mg potassium per shake
  • Lower sodium than Orgain at 280mg
Cons
  • Sweetened with sucralose
  • 170 calories per shake, 10 more than Orgain
  • Made in a facility that also processes eggs, peanuts, soy, wheat and tree nuts
  • Only one store prices it new, so there is little price competition

What separates them

30g Protein Shake - Vanilla BeanChocolate Protein Shakes
Price per 4-pack$29.94 at Amazon as of November 4, 2026$12.99 at Quest Nutrition as of November 4, 2026
FlavorVanilla beanChocolate
Protein per serving30g30g
Calories per serving160170
SweetenerNo artificial sweeteners such as sucraloseSucralose
CarrageenanCarrageenan freeGellan gum instead; no carrageenan listed
Sodium per serving350mg280mg
Calcium per servingNot listed700mg

Price history

  • 30g Protein Shake - Vanilla Bean: lowest $29.94 on Nov 4 at Amazon.
  • Chocolate Protein Shakes: lowest $26.99 on Nov 2 at BJ's Wholesale Club.

Prices at every store

30g Protein Shake - Vanilla Bean

  • TargetNew

    In stock

    $29.99+ $5.99 shippingObserved at 3:52 PM
    Visit store
  • WalmartNew

    In stockSold by Pattern

    $29.99+ $6.99 shippingObserved at 3:52 PM
    Visit store
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $29.94Observed at 3:52 PM
    Visit store

Also available at

  • OrgainCheck price at Orgain
  • OrgainCheck price at Orgain
All 3 stores and price history →

Chocolate Protein Shakes

  • Quest NutritionNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $12.99Observed at 4:44 PM
    Visit store

Also available at

  • arocep.comCheck price at arocep.com
  • BJ's Wholesale ClubCheck price at BJ's Wholesale Club
  • Easy LunchesCheck price at Easy Lunches
Prices and history →

Specs compared

Spec30g Protein Shake - Vanilla BeanChocolate Protein Shakes
Protein per serving30g30g
Total fat3g3.5g
Sodium350mg280mg
Serving size1 Carton (330 mL)1 shake (325mL)
Container size11 fl oz11 fl oz
Pack count4 x 11 fl oz4ct packs
FormReady ServeReady Serve
FlavorVanillaChocolate
IngredientsProtein, Amino AcidsProtein
Sugar per serving1g—
Calories per serving160—
Saturated fat0.5g—
Show all 24 specsShow fewer specs
Spec30g Protein Shake - Vanilla BeanChocolate Protein Shakes
Total carbohydrate4g—
Servings per container4—
Essential amino acidsall nine essential amino acids—
Amino Acid TypeBCAA—
Sugar ContentSugar Free—
Protein Grams Per Serving30 g per serving—
Total carbohydrates—4g
Total sugars—1g
Calories—170
Calcium

What reviewers say

30g Protein Shake - Vanilla Bean

With 4.8 out of 5 from 410 ratings, buyers mostly praise the taste and the protein-to-sugar ratio. The main complaints are price per carton and the limited flavor choice.

Pros
  • Smooth, creamy texture without grittiness
  • Strong 30g protein hit for the calories
  • Convenient ready-to-drink format
  • Low sugar for a protein shake
Cons
  • Cost per carton is high
  • Sweetener aftertaste for some drinkers
  • Only vanilla available
  • Pack size is small for regular users

Questions and answers

Which is better after a workout?
Both give 30g of protein per carton, so either works. Orgain has 10 fewer calories and no sucralose; Quest adds 700mg of calcium.
Is the Quest shake worth the savings?
Yes if you just want protein per dollar. At $12.99 for 4 versus $29.94 for 4, Quest costs about $3.25 per shake against about $7.49 for Orgain as of November 4, 2026.
Which has less sugar?
They are equal at 1g of sugar per serving. Orgain gets there without artificial sweeteners; Quest uses sucralose.
Does either contain carrageenan?
Orgain states it is carrageenan free. Quest lists gellan gum and no carrageenan.
Which is better for someone avoiding artificial sweeteners?
Orgain. Quest's ingredient list includes sucralose; Orgain says no artificial sweeteners such as sucralose.
How much protein is in each carton?
Both have 30g per 11 fl oz carton, with 4 cartons per pack.

More comparisons

  • 30g Protein Shake - Vanilla Bean vs Protein Shakes (12-Pack)

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best 42g protein drinks
  • Best protein shakes with 30g protein per serving
—
700mg
Potassium—310mg
Dietary fiber—1g