Which is better after a workout?

Both give 30g of protein per carton. The Slate Milk has fewer calories (130 vs 160) and is lactose-free, which may sit easier if dairy bothers you. The Orgain avoids sucralose.

Which is cheaper per shake?

Slate Milk. It is $11.99 at Target as of November 6, 2026. The Orgain 4-pack is $35.99 at Orgain, about $9.00 per carton.

Is the Slate Milk shake lactose-free?

Yes. It is made with ultra-filtered milk and lactase enzyme and is labeled lactose-free. The Orgain shake uses milk protein and is not labeled lactose-free.

Does either use artificial sweeteners?

Slate Milk uses sucralose and stevia (Reb M). Orgain says its shake has no artificial sweeteners like sucralose.

Which has fewer calories?

Slate Milk at 130 calories per can. Orgain has 160 calories per carton, with 3g fat and 350mg sodium.

Do these need refrigeration?

Slate Milk is shelf-stable and does not require refrigeration; serve it cold. Orgain is a ready-to-serve carton, best chilled before drinking.

Orgain 30g Protein Shake vs Slate Milk Cookies & Cream Protein Shake

Buy the Slate Milk Cookies & Cream if you want the better value and a dessert flavor: $11.99 at Target as of November 6, 2026, versus $35.99 at Orgain for the 4-pack of Vanilla Bean. The Orgain is the pick if you want vanilla, a 4-carton pack, and milk protein without sucralose. Both deliver 30g of protein per 11 fl oz carton with about 1g of sugar.

Today the Slate Milk Cookies & Cream Protein Shake costs $24.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.