Which is cheaper per shake?

Molk. The 12-pack is $15.19 at Amazon as of November 4, 2026, about $1.27 per carton. The Orgain 4-pack is $29.94 at Amazon, about $7.49 per carton.

Do both have 30g of protein?

Yes. Both list 30g of protein per serving. Orgain uses milk protein; Molk uses grass-fed protein.

Which has less sugar?

Molk says no added sugar and sweetens with monk fruit and Reb-M. Orgain lists 1g of sugar per serving and no artificial sweeteners.

Which is better after a workout?

Both are marketed as post-workout shakes with 30g of protein. Orgain also lists all nine essential amino acids and BCAAs, which helps if you track those.

Is the Molk price stable?

No. Its lowest daily price since November 2, 2026 was $15.19 and its highest was $39.99. Check the price history before you buy a case.

Which should I try first?

If you are unsure about the flavor, start with the Orgain 4-pack. If you already know you want a chocolate shake and want the lower price per carton, buy the Molk 12-pack.

30g Protein Shake - Vanilla Bean vs Protein Shakes (12-Pack)

Buy the Molk 12-pack if you want the lowest cost per shake and a chocolate option. Buy the Orgain 4-pack if you want a smaller trial size or a vanilla flavor. As of November 4, 2026, the Molk 12-pack is $15.19 at Amazon and the Orgain 4-pack is $29.94 at Amazon. That is about $1.27 per shake for Molk versus about $7.49 per shake for Orgain.

Today the Protein Shakes (12-Pack) costs $14.75 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.