Orgain 30g Protein Shake Vanilla Bean vs Premier Protein Chocolate Shake

Both are 30g ready-to-drink shakes with about 1g of sugar, so the choice comes down to flavor, pack size and what you want in the bottle. The Orgain Vanilla Bean is the pick for a leaner label: 160 calories, no carrageenan, no artificial sweeteners, and a smaller 4-pack that suits a trial or a short week. The Premier Protein Chocolate is the safer everyday buy for most people: a 12-pack, 24 vitamins and minerals, and a huge owner base that keeps it consistent. Owners of both praise the smooth texture; the main complaints are flavor fatigue on Orgain's single vanilla and the sweetener aftertaste some tasters note in Premier.

• Choose the Orgain 30g Protein Shake if you want a vanilla shake with a cleaner ingredient list, fewer calories and no carrageenan or artificial sweeteners, and a small pack is enough.
• Choose the Premier Protein Shake if you want a chocolate shake in a 12-pack with added vitamins and minerals and a long, well-reviewed track record.