Oliva Black Marble Cigar Ashtray vs Craftsman's Bench Polyresin Cigar Ashtray - Natural Leaf

Buy the Oliva if you want a heavy, stable ashtray that holds four cigars and stays put outdoors. Its solid marble build is far more substantial than the Craftsman's Bench polyresin, and owners of marble ashtrays generally report they last for years. The Craftsman's Bench is the better pick for a single smoker who wants a light, leaf-shaped piece for a patio table and doesn't need four rests. Reviewers of polyresin ashtrays note they resist weather but feel light and can tip in wind.

• Choose the Oliva if you smoke with company, want four cigar rests, and prefer a heavy marble piece that won't slide or blow over.
• Choose the Craftsman's Bench if you want a lighter, decorative leaf-shaped ashtray with two rests for a table indoors or on a sheltered patio.