Oliva Black Marble Cigar Ashtray vs XXinmaw Wooden Square Cigar Ashtray

Buy the Oliva if you want a heavy, stable ashtray that stays put outdoors and looks like a piece of furniture. Its solid marble body at 5.5 lbs resists wind and tipping, and four rests let four smokers share it. The XXinmaw wooden tray is lighter and adds a storage drawer for cutters and matches, but it is a generic import with thin documentation. On build and materials, the marble Oliva is the sturdier long-term piece.

• Choose the Oliva if you smoke outdoors or on a patio and want a heavy marble ashtray that will not tip or blow over.
• Choose the XXinmaw if you want a lighter wooden tray with a drawer to hold cutters, matches or caps.