XXinmaw Wooden Square Cigar Ashtray vs Craftsman's Bench Polyresin Cigar Ashtray - Natural Leaf

Buy the Craftsman's Bench if you want a durable, weather-ready ashtray with a deep bowl and a distinctive leaf design. Buy the XXinmaw if you need to rest four cigars at once and want a drawer for cutters and matches. The Craftsman's Bench is heavier and better suited to patio use; the XXinmaw is lighter wood and more of a desk organizer. Owners of polyresin ashtrays report they hold up outdoors, while wooden trays need shelter from rain.

• Choose the XXinmaw if you often have several cigars going at once or want a drawer to keep a cutter, matches and a punch handy on a desk or side table.
• Choose the Craftsman's Bench if the ashtray will live on a patio or deck and you want a deep bowl, two sturdy rests and a design that shrugs off weather.