Oliva Black Marble Cigar Ashtray vs Club Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray

Buy the Oliva if you want a heavy, solid marble ashtray that stays put on a windy patio and feels like a permanent piece of furniture. Buy the Club Macanudo if you want something light you can carry out, hose off or run through a dishwasher. The Oliva wins on build and stability; the Macanudo wins on portability and easy cleaning. Owners of marble ashtrays like the Oliva praise the weight and finish but note it is heavy to move and can chip if dropped.

• Choose the Oliva if you smoke outdoors in wind or want a weighty marble piece that anchors a table and holds four cigars at once.
• Choose the Club Macanudo if you want a light, dishwasher-safe ashtray you can move between patio, deck and table without effort.