Club Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray vs Craftsman's Bench Polyresin Cigar Ashtray - Natural Leaf

The Craftsman's Bench is the better ashtray for most cigar smokers. It has two cigar rests, a deep bowl and a heavier polyresin body that holds up outdoors, and owners of this style of leaf ashtray tend to praise the look and the rests. The Club Macanudo is a lighter, simpler melamine square with no rests, so cigars sit on the rim. Buy the Macanudo for the logo and easy dishwasher cleaning; buy the Craftsman's Bench for function and durability.

• Choose the Club Macanudo if you want a branded, dishwasher-safe square ashtray that wipes clean and matches a Macanudo-themed setup.
• Choose the Craftsman's Bench if you want two cigar rests, a deeper bowl and a heavier piece that stays put on a windy patio.