Star Cookies NY Cookie Box vs Heathcote Bakery Gourmet Cookie Three-Pack

Buy the NY Cookie box if you want big, thick stuffed cookies and the freedom to pick your own flavors; it is the stronger pick for sharing and for anyone who wants a real bakery-style 8 oz cookie. The Heathcote three-pack suits people who want smaller soft-baked cookies, a nut-free and Non-GMO option, and a simple butter or chocolate chip choice. The NY Cookie has far more ratings behind its score and a build-your-own format; Heathcote's smaller review base still rates it slightly higher, and owners on both sides praise freshness while some Heathcote buyers report crushed arrivals.

• Choose the NY Cookie if you want oversized stuffed cookies, multiple flavors in one box, and a box built to your taste.
• Choose the Gourmet Cookie Three-Pack if you want smaller soft-baked cookies that are nut-free and Non-GMO, in a simple butter or chocolate chip style.