StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Star Cookies NY Cookie Box vs Gourmet Stuffed Cookies 6-Pack

Buy the Star Cookies box if you want big, thick, bakery-style cookies in bulk and want to pick your own flavors. Buy the Gourmet 6-pack if you want a small mixed sampler of stuffed novelty flavors. The Star cookies are roughly four times heavier per piece and ship baked to order, while the Gourmet cookies are lighter, standard-size cookies built around fillings like Biscoff, Oreo and brownie. Owners rate the Star cookies highly across thousands of ratings; the Gourmet pack has far less feedback behind it.

  • Choose the Star Cookies box if you need a large box of oversized cookies, want to choose the flavors, and care about a thick, soft, fresh-baked texture.
  • Choose the Gourmet 6-pack if you want a small mixed set of stuffed flavors to try, rather than a big box of one style.

Prices

  • Star Cookies NY Cookie Box: $10.00 at Star Cookies (checked today)
  • Gourmet Stuffed Cookies 6-Pack: $49.97 at Suga Mama Sweets (checked today)
  • Difference: the Star Cookies NY Cookie Box is $39.97 cheaper than the Gourmet Stuffed Cookies 6-Pack today
T
The #1 NY Cookie

Star Cookies NY Cookie Box

The #1 NY Cookie

4.7(7,050 ratings)
$10.00at Star CookiesChecked 1 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Star Cookies
Pros
  • Very large 8 oz cookies, thick and soft
  • Build-your-own box lets you choose flavors
  • Baked to order and shipped within 48 hours
  • Strong rating base of about 7,050 reviews
Cons
  • Only sold in 30-piece boxes, so it is a lot of cookies
  • One style of cookie rather than many distinct varieties
  • Large pieces mean more cookie per serving than many people want
G
Gourmet Cookies (6 Pack)

Gourmet Stuffed Cookies 6-Pack

Gourmet Cookies (6 Pack)

4.3(3 ratings)
$49.97at Suga Mama SweetsChecked 1 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Suga Mama Sweets
Pros
  • Wide range of stuffed flavors in one pack
  • Branded fillings like Biscoff, Oreo and Nutter Butter
  • Grass-fed butter and unbleached flour
  • Small 4 and 6 packs suit single shoppers
Cons
  • Small, standard-size cookies at about 2 oz each
  • Little rating history to judge consistency
  • Flavor lineup is fixed, not build-your-own

What separates them

Star Cookies NY Cookie BoxGourmet Stuffed Cookies 6-Pack
Piece sizeAbout 8 oz (95 g) per cookie, oversizedAbout 2.05–2.25 oz per cookie, standard size
Pack sizeBoxes of 30 pieces, build-your-own flavors4, 6 or 12 packs, fixed flavor lineup
Flavor choiceYou pick the flavors in your boxSet varieties such as Birthday Party, Biscoff-stuffed and S'mores
FillingsStuffed NY-style cookies with premium chocolate and fillingsHeavy on branded fillings: Biscoff, Oreo, Nutter Butter, brownie, marshmallow
IngredientsReal butter, real eggs, premium chocolateUnbleached flour and grass-fed butter
Freshness modelBaked after you order and shipped within 48 hoursNot stated as baked to order
Track record4.7 out of 5 from about 7,050 ratingsLittle visible rating history
Best forFeeding a group or gifting a large boxA small tasting set for one or two people

Prices at every store

Star Cookies NY Cookie Box

  • Star CookiesNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $10.00Checked 1 h ago
    Visit Star Cookies
Prices and history →

Gourmet Stuffed Cookies 6-Pack

  • Suga Mama SweetsNew

    In stock

    $49.97Checked 1 h ago
    Visit Suga Mama Sweets
Prices and history →

Specs compared

SpecStar Cookies NY Cookie BoxGourmet Stuffed Cookies 6-Pack
Pack sizeboxes of 30 pieces—
Piece weight95g—
Pack Count—6-Pack ( 1/2 dozen )
Cookie Weight—2.05 - 2.25 ounces
Flour Type—unbleached flour
Butter Type—grass-fed butter

What reviewers say

Star Cookies NY Cookie Box

  • 4.7 / 57,050 ratings

With 4.7 out of 5 across more than 7,000 ratings, buyers mostly praise the size, the gooey texture and the fresh-baked arrival. Complaints center on sweetness and richness.

What people mention
  • SizePraisedBuyers say each cookie is big enough to split or save for later.
  • TexturePraisedReviewers like the crisp edge and soft, melty center.
  • FreshnessPraisedOwners report the cookies arrive fresh and well sealed.
  • SweetnessCriticisedSome buyers find the cookies overly sweet and rich.

Questions and answers

Which is better for a party or office?
The Star Cookies box. Thirty 8 oz cookies go far and you can choose the flavors. The Gourmet 6-pack is too small for a crowd.
Which has more variety?
The Gourmet pack. It offers distinct stuffed flavors like Biscoff, brownie, S'mores and cookies n' cream. The Star box is one NY-style cookie in your chosen flavors.
Which stays fresh longer?
The Star cookies are baked after you order and sealed for shipping, so they arrive fresh. The Gourmet cookies are smaller and lighter, so they dry out faster once opened.
Is the Star box worth stepping up to?
If you want big, soft, fresh-baked cookies in quantity, yes. If you only want a small tasting set of stuffed flavors, the Gourmet pack fits better.
Are the Gourmet cookies stuffed?
Yes. Most varieties have a filling such as Biscoff cookie butter, brownie, Oreo or marshmallow. The Star cookies are also stuffed, but in a thicker NY-style dough.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • The #1 NY Cookie vs Signature Cookie Assortment
  • The #1 NY Cookie vs Gourmet Cookie Three-Pack
  • The #1 NY Cookie vs Mary Macleod's Signature Gold Gift Box Ribbon Chocolate Crunch Shortbread
  • The #1 NY Cookie vs Bahlsen Deloba Puff Pastry Biscuits Cherry-Filled Gourmet Cookies - 3.5 Ounce Box (12 Pack)
  • Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box vs The #1 NY Cookie
  • Bahlsen Deloba Puff Pastry Biscuits Cherry-Filled Gourmet Cookies - 3.5 Ounce Box (12 Pack) vs Gourmet Cookies (6 Pack)

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best gourmet cookies to buy online