Star Cookies NY Cookie Box vs Gourmet Stuffed Cookies 6-Pack
Buy the Star Cookies box if you want big, thick, bakery-style cookies in bulk and want to pick your own flavors. Buy the Gourmet 6-pack if you want a small mixed sampler of stuffed novelty flavors. The Star cookies are roughly four times heavier per piece and ship baked to order, while the Gourmet cookies are lighter, standard-size cookies built around fillings like Biscoff, Oreo and brownie. Owners rate the Star cookies highly across thousands of ratings; the Gourmet pack has far less feedback behind it.
- Choose the Star Cookies box if you need a large box of oversized cookies, want to choose the flavors, and care about a thick, soft, fresh-baked texture.
- Choose the Gourmet 6-pack if you want a small mixed set of stuffed flavors to try, rather than a big box of one style.
Prices
- Star Cookies NY Cookie Box: $10.00 at Star Cookies (checked today)
- Gourmet Stuffed Cookies 6-Pack: $49.97 at Suga Mama Sweets (checked today)
- Difference: the Star Cookies NY Cookie Box is $39.97 cheaper than the Gourmet Stuffed Cookies 6-Pack today

