XXinmaw Wooden Square Cigar Ashtray vs Club Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray

Buy the Club Macanudo if you want a tough, dishwasher-safe table ashtray that survives patio use and rain. Buy the XXinmaw if you want a wooden piece with a storage drawer and four dedicated rests, and you smoke indoors or on a covered porch. The Macanudo is melamine, so it will not warp or crack like wood can, but it has no drawer and fewer defined rests. The XXinmaw looks warmer and holds accessories, but wood needs wiping, not soaking, and will weather outdoors.

• Choose the XXinmaw if you want a wooden ashtray with a storage drawer and four separate cigar rests for a desk, den or covered patio.
• Choose the Club Macanudo if you want a durable, dishwasher-safe melamine ashtray that handles outdoor table use and cleanup without fuss.