DealsBuying guidesBrandsStoresTermsPrivacydeal.ai apps

© Deal.ai Inc.

Deal.ai › Compare

L'Oreal Paris Feria Shimmering Permanent Hair Color R57 Cherry Crush vs Garnier Olia Long Lasting Permanent Hair Color Kit 6.65 Intense Red

Both are permanent red drugstore kits with 100% gray coverage, so the choice comes down to formula and finish. Olia 6.65 Intense Red is ammonia-free, oil-based and rated slightly higher (4.2 from 26,703 ratings vs 4.1 from 15,573), which makes it the safer pick for most shoppers. Feria R57 Cherry Crush is the bolder, more auburn-leaning red with a bonding conditioner, better if you want a warmer cherry tone. No prices were provided for either kit, so compare live store prices on Deal.ai before buying.

Ask our shopping agent

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

L'Oreal Paris
L'Oreal Paris Feria Shimmering Permanent Hair Color R57 Cherry Crush

L'Oreal Paris Feria Shimmering Permanent Hair Color R57 Cherry Crush

4.1· 15,573 ratings

Choose the Feria R57 Cherry Crush if you want a warm, intense medium auburn red and prefer a bonding-care conditioner in the box.

Pros
  • Warm cherry-auburn red that reads bold rather than flat
Bonding Care Complex conditioner helps weak hair feel stronger
  • 100% gray coverage
  • Widely available and heavily reviewed
  • Cons
    • Ammonia-based, harsher on sensitive scalps
    • Lower rating than Olia
    • Auburn tone may look warmer than expected on dark hair
    Garnier
    Garnier Olia Long Lasting Permanent Hair Color Kit 6.65 Intense Red

    Garnier Olia Long Lasting Permanent Hair Color Kit 6.65 Intense Red

    4.2· 26,703 ratings

    Choose the Olia 6.65 Intense Red if you want an ammonia-free, oil-based permanent red with strong shine and a large track record of ratings.

    Pros
    • Ammonia-free and oil-based, gentler on the scalp
    • Vegan and Leaping Bunny certified, no silicones, parabens or phthalates
    • Up to 3X shinier hair and a non-drip cream formula
    • Higher rating from more shoppers
    Cons
    • Oil formula can feel heavier and takes more rinsing
    • Intense Red may fade toward orange on some hair
    • Box packaging may vary

    What separates them

    L'Oreal Paris Feria Shimmering Permanent Hair Color R57 Cherry CrushGarnier Olia Long Lasting Permanent Hair Color Kit 6.65 Intense Red
    Formula baseAmmonia-based permanent color with Bonding Care Complex conditionerAmmonia-free, 60% oils with patented Oil Delivery System
    Shade toneR57 Cherry Crush, intense medium auburn (warm, cherry-leaning)6.65 Intense Red (cooler, truer red at level 6)
    Gray coverage100% gray coverage100% gray coverage
    Free-from claimsNo silicone, paraben or vegan claims statedFree from silicones, parabens and phthalates; vegan and Leaping Bunny certified
    Shine and hydration claimShimmering finish from the conditionerUp to 3X shinier than uncolored hair, non-drip cream
    ScentStandard dye scentDelicate floral fragrance
    Shopper ratings4.1 out of 5 from 15,573 ratings4.2 out of 5 from 26,703 ratings
    Kit size1 kit, single application1 kit, single application

    Price history

    • L'Oreal Paris Feria Shimmering Permanent Hair Color R57 Cherry Crush: lowest $9.99 on Nov 2 at SamsBeauty.
    • Garnier Olia Long Lasting Permanent Hair Color Kit 6.65 Intense Red: lowest $19.94 on Nov 2 at Amazon.

    Prices at every store

    L'Oreal Paris Feria Shimmering Permanent Hair Color R57 Cherry Crush

    • WalmartCheck price at Walmart
    • AmazonCheck price at Amazon
    • SamsBeautyCheck price at SamsBeauty
    Prices and history →

    Garnier Olia Long Lasting Permanent Hair Color Kit 6.65 Intense Red

    • AmazonCheck price at Amazon
    • WalmartCheck price at Walmart
    Prices and history →

    Specs compared

    SpecL'Oreal Paris Feria Shimmering Permanent Hair Color R57 Cherry CrushGarnier Olia Long Lasting Permanent Hair Color Kit 6.65 Intense Red
    hair_color_shadeR57 Cherry Crush (Intense Medium Auburn)6.65 Intense Red
    size1 Kit1
    multipack_quantity11
    colorRedRed
    actual_colorR57 Cherry Crush (Intense Medium Auburn)—

    What reviewers say

    L'Oreal Paris Feria Shimmering Permanent Hair Color R57 Cherry Crush

    Rated 4.1 out of 5 from 15,573 ratings, owners generally like the vivid color and shine, though some report faster fading and uneven gray coverage.

    Pros
    • Rich, noticeable red color
    • Good shine after conditioning
    • Easy to apply at home
    • Conditioner leaves hair soft
    Cons
    • Color fades within a few weeks
    • Gray coverage can be patchy
    • Result varies from the box picture
    • Can stain skin and towels

    Garnier Olia Long Lasting Permanent Hair Color Kit 6.65 Intense Red

    With over 26,000 ratings averaging 4.2, most owners praise the color payoff, the lack of ammonia smell and how soft hair feels afterward. The main complaints are fading speed and uneven results on darker or previously colored hair.

    Pros
    • Bright, saturated red that shows on dark hair
    • Milder smell than ammonia dyes
    • Hair feels conditioned and shiny after coloring
    • Good gray coverage
    Cons
    • Red fades within a few weeks
    • Color can come out darker or more purple than expected
    • Not enough product for long hair
    • Staining on skin and towels

    Questions and answers

    Which is better for covering gray?
    Both claim 100% gray coverage. Olia's cream is non-drip and easier to keep in place on roots, while Feria relies on its conditioner to keep hair looking healthy after coloring.
    Which red is bolder?
    Feria R57 Cherry Crush is an intense medium auburn, so it lands warmer and more cherry. Olia 6.65 Intense Red is a level 6 red that reads truer red and slightly cooler.
    Is Olia gentler on the scalp?
    Olia is ammonia-free and built on 60% oils, so it is usually the milder option. Feria is ammonia-based, which some shoppers find harsher.
    Which lasts longer?
    Both are permanent, so the base color stays until it grows out. Reds fade fastest in both lines; Olia's oil base and Feria's conditioner affect feel more than fade time.
    Is one worth paying more for?
    No prices were given for either kit, so check current store prices on Deal.ai. If they are close, Olia's higher rating and ammonia-free formula justify a small premium.
    Can I use either on previously colored hair?
    Yes, both are permanent kits. Strand-test first, and expect a warmer result on hair that already has red or auburn in it.

    More comparisons

    • L'Oreal Paris Feria Shimmering Permanent Hair Color R57 Cherry Crush vs Schwarzkopf Keratin Color Permanent Hair Color, 1.8 Ruby Noir
    • L'Oreal Paris Feria Shimmering Permanent Hair Color R57 Cherry Crush vs Revlon ColorSilk Permanent Hair Color 45 Bright Auburn
    • Revlon ColorSilk Permanent Hair Color 45 Bright Auburn vs Garnier Olia Long Lasting Permanent Hair Color Kit 6.65 Intense Red

    Buying guides that pick them

    • Best permanent at-home hair color kits in vivid red